Most people asking this fall into one of two camps. Some are thinking about buying a property to let. Others already own one, often a home they've moved out of or inherited, and are deciding whether to keep letting it or sell. The answer differs, but the maths is the same.
This isn't financial advice. It's a way to look at the numbers before you talk to a mortgage broker or accountant.
The short answer
Buy-to-let can still work, but less often than it did a decade ago. It tends to make sense when you have plenty of equity and a small mortgage, pay basic-rate tax, plan to hold for the long term and keep running costs down. It struggles when the mortgage is large, you pay higher-rate tax and you're paying top-end agent fees.
A worked example
Take a home worth £293,000 let at £1,459 a month. Those are the average house price and average rent for England from the ONS. That's £17,508 a year in rent: a gross yield of about 6%.
Now take off typical running costs. These are illustrative, not quotes:
- Full management at 14.4% including VAT: about £2,520
- Insurance, certificates and servicing: say £700
- Repairs and maintenance: say £1,200
- Empty periods between tenants: say £500 a year on average
That leaves about £12,600 before any mortgage and tax. Without a mortgage, that's a return of roughly 4.3% a year on the property's value, before any rise or fall in its price.
Add a mortgage and the picture changes. Interest-only borrowing of £200,000 at 5% costs £10,000 a year, leaving about £2,600. Under section 24 you can't deduct mortgage interest from your rental profit; you get a tax credit instead, worth 20% of the interest now and 22% from April 2027. So a basic-rate taxpayer would pay about £500 in tax and keep around £2,000 a year. A higher-rate taxpayer would owe about £3,000 and end up roughly £450 a year out of pocket.
The size of the mortgage and your tax band move the result more than anything else. The agent's fee is next, and it's the easiest to change: see what letting agents charge in 2026.
What's changed for landlords
- Tax. Separate property income tax rates of 22%, 42% and 47% start in April 2027, two points higher than today. Making Tax Digital adds quarterly reporting for landlords with income over £50,000 now, £30,000 from April 2027 and £20,000 from April 2028.
- The Renters' Rights Act. No fixed terms, no section 21, and four months' notice if you want the property back to sell or move in, never in the first year. Use those grounds and you can't re-let for 12 months.
- Energy efficiency. Rented homes will need EPC band C by October 2030, with up to £10,000 of spending required.
- Registration. A landlord register costing £65 per property per year opens region by region from December 2026.
If you already own it: keep or sell?
For accidental landlords the real question is usually whether to keep letting a home you already own. Reasons to keep it:
- You'd like to live in it again, or pass it on, and the rent covers the costs in the meantime.
- Selling now would mean accepting a price you think is too low.
- The mortgage is small or paid off, so the numbers work in your favour.
Reasons to sell:
- The rent no longer covers the mortgage, tax and running costs.
- You'd rather have the money working elsewhere, or out of property altogether.
- Being a landlord, even through an agent, is costing more time and worry than it's worth.
If you might sell in the next few years, plan around the new possession rules, or consider selling with the tenant in place.
And before you decide letting doesn't pay, check what you're paying your agent. On a £1,459 rent, the difference between 12% and 18% including VAT is over £1,000 a year.
Free, and it takes 2 minutes
Keep, sell or switch? Start with the numbers
Type your property's address. We'll check the letting agents nearby on published fees, reviews and client money protection, then email you a side-by-side report, usually within 10 minutes. It's free.
- Fees
- Reviews
- Protections
Nothing goes to an agent without your sign-off.
