Letting agents in Sheffield: fees compared

· Sheffield, S1, S2, S3, S4, S5, S6 and 11 more

On average, full management with a Sheffield letting agent costs 14.5% of the rent, including VAT, and rent collection costs 12%. We checked 682 individual fees, line by line, from the agencies' published fee documents.

Sheffield letting fees at a glance

Full management
14.5%
average, inc VAT
Rent collection
12%
average, inc VAT
Letting agencies
146
with a branch in S1, S2, S3, S4, S5, S6 and 11 more
Fees checked
682
every set-up, renewal and exit fee
Compare all 146 agencies

Averages include VAT and cover the agencies that publish each fee.

Sheffield letting agents by full management fee

Management fee as a share of the rent. Extras rate each agency's one-off set-up fees against the others here.

  1. 1Hallam Hills7–8.4%4.1 out of 5 from 13 Google reviewsVAT not statedFee clarity 1/5Extras: n/a
  2. 2Prop Home Sheffield7.2% + £5004.2 out of 5 from 26 Google reviewsinc VATFee clarity 4/5Extras: High
  3. 3Henry Spencer & Sons10%4.3 out of 5 from 75 Google reviewsinc VATFee clarity 3/5Extras: High
  4. 4Sheffield Estate Agents9% + £2505.0 out of 5 from 4 Google reviewsinc VATFee clarity 3/5Extras: n/a
  5. 5Key2go10% + £2404.6 out of 5 from 333 Google reviewsinc VATFee clarity 3/5Extras: Low
  6. 6Hunters Chapeltown10% + £3004.4 out of 5 from 110 Google reviewsinc VATFee clarity 3/5Extras: Medium
  7. 7Sourced Living Chapeltown8% + £7804.1 out of 5 from 84 Google reviewsinc VATFee clarity 3/5Extras: n/a
  8. 8Crucible Homes8% + £7803.6 out of 5 from 20 Google reviewsinc VATFee clarity 4/5Extras: Low

Extras are the one-off fees for a new fully managed tenancy that the management fee doesn't cover, such as a flat set-up fee, inventory, referencing and deposit registration. Low is the cheapest third of Sheffield agencies, High the priciest third; n/a means not published.

Fee clarity (out of 5) is how clearly each agency publishes its fees. Not a measure of value or service. Where an agency doesn't say if VAT is included, we show a range and rank on the higher figure. How we compare agents

Fees not published

67 agencies

These agencies don't publish a full management fee we can compare. Letting agents must publish their fees, including VAT.

Work at an agency here?

Already let through a Sheffield agent? You can switch and keep your tenant

We'll check your contract for exit fees first, then handle the handover.

Check my contract

Sheffield letting agent fees: questions

From each agency's website and published fee documents, Google and public registers. Fees checked 20 November 2026.

Report something wrong

What would you really pay?

Free, with no phone calls

Compare agents