Stuart Smith
Letting agent · Derby, DE1 ·
Stuart Smith charges landlords 12% + £430 inc VAT for full management, below the Derby average of 14%. It has 3.7 stars from 45 Google reviews.
· Sources
Fees vs 49 Derby agents
Full management fee, inc VAT, of the 49 Derby agents that publish one. Lowest 3.4%, average 14% (dashed line), highest 22.2%.
See the fee breakdownBudgy's take: Stuart Smith is a single-office, independent Derby agency that describes itself as a long-established managing agent. Expect a local team that knows Derby and the surrounding area, rather than a national chain's call centre.
Stuart Smith fees
As published on its website, inc VAT. Ratings compare prices with other Derby agents.
View Stuart Smith fees pageManagement fees
Price rating: MediumA share of the rent. Rated on full management.
| Fee | Stuart Smith |
|---|---|
| Full managementFinds the tenant and manages the let | 12% + £430Derby avg 14% |
| Rent collectionFinds the tenant and collects the rent | Not publishedWe'll ask for you |
| Tenant findFinds and sets up the tenant only | 9.23%Derby avg 7.8% |
Other fees
Price rating: HighOne-off charges, such as setting up a tenancy or leaving. Rated as a group.
See all 13 other fees
| Fee | Stuart Smith |
|---|---|
| Energy Performance CertificateFlat fee · When arranged | £102 |
| Key cuttingFirst key £18; additional keys £6 each · When requested. From April 2024 schedule. | £18 |
| Inventory (Let Only)Flat fee for full written inventory, photographs and meter readings · Start of tenancy, let only | £144 |
| Protection of tenancy deposit with DPS (Let Only)Flat fee · Start of tenancy, let only. From April 2024 schedule. | £114 |
| Renewal agreement feeFlat fee · On renewal. From April 2024 schedule. | £96 |
| Lease renewal to include rent increase (managed)Flat fee · On renewal, fully managed. From April 2024 schedule. | £60 |
| Serving of Section 13 rent increase noticeFlat fee · When served. From April 2024 schedule. | £60 |
| Additional inspectionsFlat fee per extra inspection at landlord request · When requested. From April 2024 schedule. | £60 |
| Serving of Section 21 on Landlord's instructionFlat fee · When served. From April 2024 schedule. | £120 |
| Tenancy Deposit Dispute Resolution Claim - swearing of the oathFlat fee · When a claim is made. From April 2024 schedule. | £42 |
| Sale of the property to a tenant1% + VAT of purchase price · On sale to tenant. From April 2024 schedule. | 1.2% |
| Early Determination Fee - landlord sells with tenants in situFlat fee · If landlord sells while tenants in situ. From April 2024 schedule. | £500 |
| Landlord takes over management and retains tenantOne month's rent plus VAT (example: £450 rent = £540) · If landlord takes over management and keeps the tenant. From April 2024 schedule. Percent here is of one month's rent (8.33% of annual rent... shown as 120% of monthly rent inc VAT). | 100% |
Source: Stuart Smith fees page, checked 18 November 2026. Not yet confirmed by the agency
Fee transparency
Some gapsPublishes its management fee, VAT and set-up fees, but not fees updated for the Renters' Rights Act and a notice period or commission term.
- Published: Management fee12% + £430 for full management.
- Published: Is VAT includedAll fees shown inc VAT.
- Published: Clear, complete feesPublishes a detailed breakdown of all the costs for landlords.
- Not published: Up to dateStill shows fees the Renters' Rights Act ended, such as for renewing fixed-term tenancies.
- Not published: Exit termsNo notice period or commission term published.
How clearly Stuart Smith publishes its fees, from its website on 18 November 2026. Not a measure of value or service.
One of the quieter agents in DE1
Stuart Smith has 1 home advertised to rent in DE1, joint 43rd most of the 61 agents advertising there. More local stock means more tenants looking and a better feel for what homes like yours rent for.
| Homes | Rank | Listed |
|---|---|---|
| Studio | None listed | 0 of 10 |
| 1 bed | None listed | 0 of 242 |
| 2 bed | joint 23rd of 27 | 1 of 138 |
| 3 bed | None listed | 0 of 55 |
| 4+ bed | None listed | 0 of 27 |
| All homes | joint 43rd of 61 | 1 of 500 |
Median asking rent £825 a month.
Homes advertised to rent in DE1 by the local agents we track, checked 22 Nov 2026. Lets that are never advertised aren't included.
Poorly reviewed, below the Derby average
Stuart Smith scores 3.7 on Google from 45 reviews. The average Derby agent scores 4.6, so small gaps matter. Read the recent landlord reviews, not just the score.
Source: Google and Trustpilot
We couldn't confirm any register check yet
Every letting agent in England must belong to a redress scheme and hold client money protection. Ask Stuart Smith for their certificates before you sign.
- Redress scheme memberNot checked yet
- Client money protectionNot checked yet
- Property Ombudsman expelled listNot checked yet
- Property tribunal decisionsNot checked yet
Company health
All clearStuart Smith (Derby) Limited (04699940)
- Status. Active, trading since 2003
- Annual accounts. Up to date, made up to 31 March 2026
- Confirmation statement. Up to date, next due 27 March 2027
- Insolvency history. None on record
Source: Companies House, 19 Nov 2026
Compare Stuart Smith against other local agents
See how Stuart Smith compares with every Derby agent for your property, then let Budgy get the quotes and negotiate the fees.
- Tell us about your propertyYour address and a few questions about the let. About 2 minutes.
- See your shortlistThe best Derby agents for your property, Stuart Smith included, with first-year costs at your rent.
- We get the quotesWe email the agents and push for better fees. They see the property, not you. Quotes usually arrive in 1 to 3 days.
- You chooseWe introduce you to the agent you pick. Nothing is agreed without you.
Start here
Free, with no phone calls. Agents don't get your name, email or number unless you choose.
Stuart Smith, answered
How much does Stuart Smith charge landlords?
Stuart Smith charges 12% + £430 for full management and 9.23% for tenant find, inc VAT. It doesn't publish a rent-collection fee. The Derby average for full management is 14%. Set-up fees such as inventory (Let Only) (£144) and protection of tenancy deposit with DPS (Let Only) (£114) are on top.
What does it cost to leave Stuart Smith?
Stuart Smith's published tenancy Deposit Dispute Resolution Claim - swearing of the oath is £42. Check its notice period too, and get both in writing before you sign or give notice.
Does Stuart Smith charge renewal fees?
Stuart Smith's published fees still include charges the Renters’ Rights Act ended, such as for renewing fixed-term tenancies. Ask whether it still charges them before you sign.
What is Stuart Smith's tenant-find fee?
Stuart Smith charges 9.23% for tenant find, inc VAT (Derby average 7.8%).
Is Stuart Smith a good letting agent?
Stuart Smith charges landlords 12% + £430 inc VAT for full management, below the Derby average of 14%. It has 3.7 stars from 45 Google reviews.
How many Derby letting agents charge less than Stuart Smith?
21 of the 49 Derby agents that publish a full-management fee charge less than Stuart Smith's 13.8%. The lowest is 3.4% and the average is 14%.
How do I switch from Stuart Smith to another agent?
Check your contract for the notice period and any exit fee. Stuart Smith lists a £42 tenancy Deposit Dispute Resolution Claim - swearing of the oath. Get quotes from other Derby agents before you give notice so there's no gap in management.
Will agents call me if I use Budgy?
Not unless you ask. When Budgy negotiates, agents see the property, not your name, email or number.
From Stuart Smith's fee schedule and website, Google, Trustpilot, Companies House and public registers. Unverified until the agency confirms. Checked: Fees 18 Nov 2026, listings 22 Nov 2026, reviews 18 Nov 2026, Companies House 19 Nov 2026. How we compare agents
Work at Stuart Smith?
Confirm your fees and terms so landlords see accurate details. Claiming is free.
What would you really pay?
Free, with no phone calls